WIN: Who is Next & Lore’s Journey through Idol Eliminations

WIN

I tend to get a little obsessed. Ask my parents – anytime I started to like something I brought it to the point of overkill. I liked the American Girls series in my youth – I decorated my entire room Felicity -like and went through a weird fascination with the Revolutionary War. I started to like the Beatles as I hit my teenage years – yep, my entire wall was covered. As a twenty something I started to like Korean dramas, yes Mom and Dad that is what I talk about when I come to visit. So it is no surprise that as soon as WIN: Who is Next hooked me I went all cray cray and marathoned every show that was possibly similar. Yep, here comes the WIN-and-every-elimination-show-I-have-watched-thus-far ramble. You may want to grab some soju and ramyun, this is going to take a while.

WIN: Who is Next (2013)

The first group elimination show I watched, I became way toooo emotionally invested in this show. Or maybe I was just a human watching this battle between young men that had a desire to debut. Either way, I really wanted this to be a win for every YG trainee participating in the shoot.

WIN 5

Earlier today, the winner was announced, Team A. I admit I cheered for this team, but I liked Team B as well. I found the entire format largely trying on fans and the participants alike; it is hard to meet 11 people and know that roughly half of them are participating with an end result of failure.

Team A

What I liked about this show: The stakes were better played out than other elimination shows I have watched. If they win – if they lose becomes much more than an imaginative situation and more of a realistic downfall. Which makes this show all the more bittersweet.

Team B

What I hated: The obvious, an entire team elimination (the pro of this show is the con of this show…aissshhhh so confused!). This was not a story of a person here or there that failed (not that in any way that format is more comforting- the single elimination) this was an entire group ousted at once. After listening to the boy’s stories it was hard to come to a satisfactory conclusion.

Watch it: YG Princes Subs

Big Bang Documentary (2006)

Before WIN came Big Bang Documentary, following six idol hopefuls as they prepared to be YG’s newest act. Sound familiar? Yeah, this was kind of WIN 7 years ago. Watch G-Dragon, Tae Yang, and T.O.P. battle it out alongside B2ST’s Hyunseung.

bb docu 1

What I liked about this show: It is all in retrospect because I know who makes up Big Bang. Yet I cannot help but cheer at seeing the youthful trainee versions of this group, because they were daebak back then (just as they are now).

bb docu 32

What I hated: I could say the eliminations again, but I will not. What I hated was the pacing discord, I never quite got how this show was supposed to present itself. From long, drawn out montages to realistic looks at our boys practicing, this was an uneven reality show.

Watch it: BB Docu

Hot Blood (2008)

The groups 2AM and 2PM were born of this show, pitting 12 trainees in a hardcore battle (that involves marine training – yep- seriously) to see who could survive.

Hot Blood

What I liked about this show: The variety was daebak. From rapping to learning folk songs, the contestants really were at odds with what was thrown their way.

hot blood 2

What I hated: Was it really necessary to put them in a coffin? I mean- really?! Here is looking at you JYP!

Watch it: time2sub

B2ST Documentary (2009)

A natural progression from the 2 prior shows I mentioned, the B2ST documentary features someone that was eliminated from Big Bang and someone that was eliminated from Hot Blood. Often called the “recycled group” B2ST is made up of those that have found a second chance after prior rejection or failure in the world of Korean pop. I heart these kids. In a non-creepy noona is cheering for you kind of way.

beast

What I liked about this show: The underdogs! I loved catching up with the boys that found another chance (rightfully so).

best 3

What I hated: Ummm…do flash backs about eliminations count?!

Watch it: BEAST Docu

Parting Thoughts

Papa YG- Let them both debut. Preeeettttttty please?!

please

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “WIN: Who is Next & Lore’s Journey through Idol Eliminations

  1. WIN was the first show like this I’ve watched and it will be the last. I got way too involved in the kids, and I was too upset by the end (I get overly obsessed with things too). This line exactly – “I found the entire format largely trying on fans and the participants alike; it is hard to meet 11 people and know that roughly half of them are participating with an end result of failure.”

    • I have a hard time thinking about watching another one of these shows. Somehow it works that I was catching up on older ones (at least in my head) – that way I knew kind of how it turned out. WIN was far too brutal on my emotions.

  2. A coffin?!? Wtf?
    I barely survived WIN, and I only let myself obsess about it for a little under 2 weeks. Not sure I could’ve handled it starting 10 weeks ago. Not sure I ever want to go through this again. 😥

Ramble On...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s